The writing standard

Of our local writers and Mir Khalid''s views about them

Imtiyaz Assad
Srinagar, Publish Date: Dec 14 2017 10:43PM | Updated Date: Dec 14 2017 10:43PM
The writing standardFile Photo

Close on the heels of an interview by Gowher Geelani with Mir Khalid, the author of Jaffna Street, published in Kashmir Ink Magazine, some guys rolled up their sleeves, pulled up their socks and started hauling Mir Khalid over the coals for calling "native writers" as "Wannabes" and many other things which they took umbrage at, as if the author had committed a sheer profanity by simply calling a spade a spade.

I wonder, why a massive tide of anger overtakes us when someone speaks an unsavoury truth that we find hard to swallow? Mir Khalid is right in his conclusions. What great corpus of literature have we produced that we can brag about? Can any of the works churned out by our lionised authors and that of Camus, Kafka or for that matter Dostoevsky - be put in the same league? I don't deny the fact that in a conflict-torn state, if someone raises a voice of protest by writing a book, he ought to greeted with plaudits, but glorifying the half-baked stuff is asinine at best and unpalatable at worst.

Well, I happened to see a particular self-styled Gabriel Garcia Marquez on social media - fulminating against the stylistic facet of Khalid's writing. This is a classical example of: Grapes are sour. He does not know that to acquire writing skills and literary flair of Khalid, it will take him decades together and yet he will be still languishing at the margins - cursing his fate. Another pseudo intellectual has - out of sheer frustration -  tried to pour ridicule upon Gowher Geelani despite the fact the latter is just an interviewer and plainly states what interviewee puts across; so what is the point of aiming your impotent weapons at him?

Well, coming back to my point. Sympathy with our local writers is good, but it must not make us blithely brush aside the enormous fund of literature French, Russian or British or American writers have produced. Khalid is right when he says had "brilliant tour de force works" been written, our aspiring young writers could have drawn inspiration from them. Why should it get on our nerves when it is purely in our better interest and likely to act an impetus to the active breed of writers to give birth to something great and set a glorious example? We celebrate mediocrity, and make holy cows of our local authors who are yet to step out of their narrow orbits and shed their goddamn hubris.

However I do disagree with Mir Khalid when he accuses our "poetry dabblers" and prose "afficiandos" of not having ever heard of Emily Dickinson, David Remnick and Kazuo Ishiguro. This is nothing short of scoffing at the literary tastes of our young poets and prose writers and should not have come from writer of Khalid's stature. I know a huge number of local poets and prose writers who have read a plenty of serious stuff - more profound and sublime than David Remnick and Kazuo Ishiguro, so this impression by Mir Khalid carries no substance.

To end with, I must say, we have a young lot of writers who are endowed with massive potential and are capable of writing good stuff.They need to set sights high and aim higher, as suggested by Mir Khalid. So long as we are unable to produce Dostoevsky and his ilk, Khalid's seemingly blunt and bitter remarks will continue to rankle our nerves.

 

  • More in this Category
  • A Tryst of the Heart and History along the Karakoram Highway

    A Tryst of the Heart and History along the Karakoram Highway

    Probably the only Kashmiri leader having roots, presence and following in all three divided regions of the Jammu & Kashmir state, he shunned personal grandeur – that many thought would accrue by burial in AJK and insisted on a Gilgit burial instead.

Latest News

  1. Two SPOs, civilian wounded in Kulgam grenade blast: Police
  2. Two SPOs, civilian wounded in Kulgam grenade blast: Police
  1. Cop arrested with heroin in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Cop arrested with heroin in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Pakistan always stood like a rock guarding Kashmir cause: Geelani
  2. Pakistan always stood like a rock guarding Kashmir cause: Geelani
  1. Iran's Khamenei urges Muslims to withstand US 'bullying'
  2. Iran's Khamenei urges Muslims to withstand US 'bullying'
  1. Civilian injured in Anantnag militant attack succumbs
  2. Civilian injured in Anantnag militant attack succumbs
  1. Kathua case: Bar Council supports CBI probe, says lawyers didn’t block challan
  2. Kathua case: Bar Council supports CBI probe, says lawyers didn’t block challan
  1. Civilian killed after car-borne gunmen attack govt forces in Anantnag
  2. Civilian killed after car-borne gunmen attack govt forces in Anantnag
  1. SC will transfer Kathua trial out of Jammu and Kashmir on 'slightest' sign of unfairness
  2. SC will transfer Kathua trial out of Jammu and Kashmir on 'slightest' sign of unfairness
  1. Pakistan-administered Kashmir boy who inadvertently entered Poonch repatriated
  2. Pakistan-administered Kashmir boy who inadvertently entered Poonch repatriated
  1. Sharing information key to ward off cyber threats: Report
  2. Sharing information key to ward off cyber threats: Report
  1. Noted educationist Ghulam Mustafa Shaheen passes away at Anantnag residence
  2. Noted educationist Ghulam Mustafa Shaheen passes away at Anantnag residence
  1. IUST Awantipora students protest against alleged forces high-handedness
  2. IUST Awantipora students protest against alleged forces high-handedness
  1. India has become land of gang rapists: Mallika Sherawat
  2. India has become land of gang rapists: Mallika Sherawat
  1. Jammu and Kashmir: India, Pakistan trade fire along LoC in Rajouri
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: India, Pakistan trade fire along LoC in Rajouri
  1. Not elevating U'khand CJ to SC exposes PM's revenge politics: Congress
  2. Not elevating U'khand CJ to SC exposes PM's revenge politics: Congress
  1. Day after his transfer order, govt retains officer probing Kangan youth’s killing
  2. Day after his transfer order, govt retains officer probing Kangan youth’s killing
  1. Kashmir University orders probe after scuffle among law students
  2. Kashmir University orders probe after scuffle among law students
  1. Lawyer moves SC alleging contemptuous remarks by advocates, politicians
  2. Lawyer moves SC alleging contemptuous remarks by advocates, politicians
  1. Kashmir to see more bloodshed this year, claims former J&K police chief
  2. Kashmir to see more bloodshed this year, claims former J&K police chief
  1. SC to consider Kathua accused's plea to transfer probe to CBI
  2. SC to consider Kathua accused's plea to transfer probe to CBI
  1. Singapore Airlines to launch world's longest non-stop flight
  2. Singapore Airlines to launch world's longest non-stop flight
  1. Operational commander of Jaish was among four militants killed in Tral gunfight: DGP
  2. Operational commander of Jaish was among four militants killed in Tral gunfight: DGP
  1. UN reports dire humanitarian situation in Syria
  2. UN reports dire humanitarian situation in Syria
  1. 13 school children killed in UP accident
  2. 13 school children killed in UP accident