J&K BUDGET: Financial sorcery and political poetry

Sarwar Gulzar
Srinagar, Publish Date: Jan 22 2018 11:19PM | Updated Date: Jan 22 2018 11:19PM
J&K BUDGET: Financial sorcery and political poetry

Of late, the financial poetry surrounding J&K’s annual budget proceedings leaves the legislative house bewildered and awestricken. The opposition most of the times ends up shooting aimless blunt arrows as an instant reaction. Mitigating the fear of getting exposed with their limited financial vocabulary and understanding most of the members of the house prefer remaining mum instead.

Unlike old wostas, who used to drive this yearly financial bus in their own vernacular style, the new driver happens to be an experienced and well-read mechanical engineer. His passion with the specifications of bus engine and mechanics (read budgeting and accounting) is so vivid that he at times forgets that the bus is also about its passengers. He prefers to spend most of his time explaining the benefits of newly incorporated features like anti lock braking system, automatic fuel transmission, airbags, suspension, engine torque, displacement and turn radius (read BEAMS, PAO system, PFMS etc) of the bus. He also makes it a point to remind his passengers about the very irresponsible and unprofessional approach of old wostas, which has made this miserable bus extremely fuel inefficient (read recurring revenue expenditure). In addition to a pile of unpaid fuel bills, the old wostas have also recruited an army of support staff for maintenance, security and administration of this bus (read government employees and casual labourers).

The problem with the new driver is that despite his fourth year as the incharge of this mega financial bus of the state, he is still stuck with two things: either bashing old wostas or boasting about the upgraded vehicle specifications. In the process, the passengers are left with no option but to wait tirelessly for the bus to take off. The problem at hand is that the fare given by the passengers (read tax collections) is far less than the expenditure on the bus (read salaries for support staff and fuel bills). This leads the otherwise smart driver to tread the path of the old wostas i.e. to borrow money from the banks.

To ensure that he remains the driver for more terms to come, he starts to explore means as to how he can calm the passengers who by now have started to protest because of the poor cabin condition of the bus and bumpy roads (read economic slump). He does this by offering more jobs in the already overburdened bus administration team (read regularization of daily wagers) and not only that, he also hikes salaries of the existing staff with many freebies (e.g. 7th Pay commission, DA etc). With all this expenditure, the debt of the bus keeps on mounting and the welfare and safety of the poor passengers keeps on taking a back seat. This leaves very little money for investing in creating more seats in the bus and improving the condition of deteriorated roads (improving tax base through capital expenditure).

While justifying his decision of showering pleasantries on the government employees, the learned man said that this is not just about 5 lakh employees, its about 20 lakh people (5 lakh house holds he meant) and he also said that this will improve the demand pull in the economy. But we humbly remind him that it lacks sustainability. I think he has never heard of the great proverb, “if you give a man a fish, you will feed him for the day but if you teach a man how to fish, you will feed him for his entire life”. Our finance minister chose to distribute fish rather than investing in creating income generating avenues. All the reforms he invested so much of time and energy in will show impact in the long run-that is what he says, almost, always. But who gets to see that “long run”? John Maynard Keynes, the famous British economist, wisely quoted “In the long run we are all Dead”.

 

Author is based in Srinagar and writes about political and economic issues

 

Latest News

  1. Court seeks status report in Major Gogoi hotel incident
  2. Court seeks status report in Major Gogoi hotel incident
  1. Govt pre-pones vacations for summer zone schools
  2. Govt pre-pones vacations for summer zone schools
  1. Muslim youth beaten up for befriending Hindu girl
  2. Muslim youth beaten up for befriending Hindu girl
  1. Mehbooba welcomes Rajnath’s dialogue offer, hopes Hurriyat seizes the opportunity
  2. Mehbooba welcomes Rajnath’s dialogue offer, hopes Hurriyat seizes the opportunity
  1. Petrol prices rise for 13th straight day; almost Rs 78 in Delhi
  2. Petrol prices rise for 13th straight day; almost Rs 78 in Delhi
  1. Modi doesn't advocate peace talks: Musharraf
  2. Modi doesn't advocate peace talks: Musharraf
  1. Mehbooba congratulates Sama for topping in JK CBSE class 12 results
  2. Mehbooba congratulates Sama for topping in JK CBSE class 12 results
  1. People now know Modi-Shah duo harmful for country: Congress
  2. People now know Modi-Shah duo harmful for country: Congress
  1. Truck plunges into gorge on Kashmir highway, one killed
  2. Truck plunges into gorge on Kashmir highway, one killed
  1. NIA arrests Kupwara resident in Nagrota army camp attack case
  2. NIA arrests Kupwara resident in Nagrota army camp attack case
  1. Army schools in Kashmir take a digital leap
  2. Army schools in Kashmir take a digital leap
  1. Youth held with grenade in Srinagar
  2. Youth held with grenade in Srinagar
  1. Yasin Malik hits out at New Delhi as JRL stages protest to demand release of prisoners
  2. Yasin Malik hits out at New Delhi as JRL stages protest to demand release of prisoners
  1. Shabir Shah's daughter tops Jammu and Kashmir in CBSE class 12 results
  2. Shabir Shah's daughter tops Jammu and Kashmir in CBSE class 12 results
  1. Four years of Modi: Congress slams BJP over farmers' suicides, unemployment
  2. Four years of Modi: Congress slams BJP over farmers' suicides, unemployment
  1. Girls outshine boys in CBSE Class 12 results
  2. Girls outshine boys in CBSE Class 12 results
  1. Shutdown in Downtown Srinagar against ‘police high-handedness’
  2. Shutdown in Downtown Srinagar against ‘police high-handedness’
  1. Pakistan rejects charge of treating US diplomats badly
  2. Pakistan rejects charge of treating US diplomats badly
  1. North Kashmir: Amid shutdown, hundreds protest Hajin civilian killing
  2. North Kashmir: Amid shutdown, hundreds protest Hajin civilian killing
  1. No confusion in our Kashmir policy; ready to talk to Hurriyat, Pakistan: Rajnath Singh
  2. No confusion in our Kashmir policy; ready to talk to Hurriyat, Pakistan: Rajnath Singh
  1. Pak Army summons former ISI head over book co-authored with ex-RAW chief
  2. Pak Army summons former ISI head over book co-authored with ex-RAW chief
  1. Modi says 'India First' as government completes four years
  2. Modi says 'India First' as government completes four years
  1. Overbooked Air India flight leaves passengers behind; airline spokesman calls it 'rare occurence'
  2. Overbooked Air India flight leaves passengers behind; airline spokesman calls it 'rare occurence'
  1. Iran more confident to save nuke deal after US exit: Official
  2. Iran more confident to save nuke deal after US exit: Official
  1. Infiltration bid foiled, four militants killed in north Kashmir: Army
  2. Infiltration bid foiled, four militants killed in north Kashmir: Army