Beyond shutdowns

Who has made hartal the only available option?

AJAZ UL HAQUE
Srinagar, Publish Date: Jan 13 2018 11:11PM | Updated Date: Jan 13 2018 11:11PM
Beyond shutdownsFile Photo

Mirwaiz Umar Farooq puts shutdown as the “only option left with the resistance leadership to attract the attention of the world community towards the sufferings of Kashmiris.” The statement merits a comment. 

Hartal has entered our social lingo. It has become an inseparable part of our resistance discourse. There is no dispute that it is a way through which we register our resistance. There can't be any cast-iron answer to the question as to whether we should do it or not? This sure is the most peaceful and the least violent method of protest. In some desperate cases it remains to be the only necessary evil to be invoked against oppression. But making this as the `only option' makes it not just ineffective, but dead, not just dead but self-immolating. Any sudden oppressive action causes a natural, automatic and spontaneous reaction in the form of a shutdown. Protest is the weapon of the weak, but its overuse renders it hollow and that is what our resistance leadership has made it.  If they prick us, shall we not bleed. Thus goes the logic. This no doubt is our way of telling the world that we are bleeding. Meanwhile does the world care or (if we rephrase the question even more indifferently) does the world know that we suffer or we exist? When mighty rule, who bothers about the weak. Though that must not deaden our spirit of resistance, but that should also open our eyes towards some facts we refuse to accept.

Some years back Mirwaiz himself invited civil society to debate the effectiveness of hartal and explore alternatives. Even if we accept hartal as an inevitability, shouldn't we edit the whole hartal calendar. If we mark a militant's funeral as hartal, chaharum as hartal, anniversary as hartal, some rumoured shrine-desecration or scripture-defilement as hartal, Trump's tantrums as hartals, middle-east crisis as hartal, braid-chopping as hartal, leaders' imprisonment as hartal – even the whole year will fall short to complete the hartal course. Like there are ways and ways to skin a cat, there are more ways to commemorate our past, to show resistance, to remember those we lost and those we are losing.  Resistance, as a law of physics, will invite oppression and oppression as a law of reason evokes anger. What matters is the language through which we route our anger. If I starve, who will die. Prolonged shutdowns have prolonged our agony in the past too. We tested (and tasted) it in 2010 and six years after when we pushed ourselves into a deep and irrevocable mess. Meanwhile if you call for shutdown who pays the price? The moral question we need to think over. 

Moreover if hartal is an option against injustice, let it not be a single brand of injustice which we are against. If we protest against innocent killings, the canvass of this `innocence' must not be confined to one set only. That may go against the gammer of the resistance politics, but that will make hartal a politics-neutral, ideology neutral method of protest. Killing is killing and innocents die on either side. Why be violent on one and silent on the other. 

Latest News

  1. RSS won't accept Muslims: Mayawati
  2. RSS won't accept Muslims: Mayawati
  1. BJP controlling media by filing police cases against journalists: Kejriwal
  2. BJP controlling media by filing police cases against journalists: Kejriwal
  1. India, Pakistan foreign ministers to meet in New York
  2. India, Pakistan foreign ministers to meet in New York
  1. BSP not to contest ULB elections in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. BSP not to contest ULB elections in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Four women in shortlist of six for Man Booker 2018
  2. Four women in shortlist of six for Man Booker 2018
  1. SC reserves order on SIT probe into activists' arrest
  2. SC reserves order on SIT probe into activists' arrest
  1. Triple talaq ordinance undemocratic: CPI-M
  2. Triple talaq ordinance undemocratic: CPI-M
  1. Tribute | Death Of Jessi, Kashmir’s Maxim Mikhaylov, Leaves Fans Devastated
  2. Tribute | Death Of Jessi, Kashmir’s Maxim Mikhaylov, Leaves Fans Devastated
  1. Muslim labourer’s killer Shambhulal Regar offered ticket to contest 2019 Lok Sabha polls
  2. Muslim labourer’s killer Shambhulal Regar offered ticket to contest 2019 Lok Sabha polls
  1. Quran reading at Goa BJP office held for Parrikar's recovery
  2. Quran reading at Goa BJP office held for Parrikar's recovery
  1. Gunfight breaks out in Bandipora in north Kashmir
  2. Gunfight breaks out in Bandipora in north Kashmir
  1. Pakistan PM Khan writes to Modi seeking resumption of peace dialogue with India: report
  2. Pakistan PM Khan writes to Modi seeking resumption of peace dialogue with India: report
  1. Jammu and Kashmir acting DGP Dilbag Singh to continue in office, says SC
  2. Jammu and Kashmir acting DGP Dilbag Singh to continue in office, says SC
  1. Ganderbal minor was murdered in fit of rage, accused arrested: Kashmir Police
  2. Ganderbal minor was murdered in fit of rage, accused arrested: Kashmir Police
  1. Pakistan issues postage stamps portraying slain Kashmir militant commander Burhan Wani
  2. Pakistan issues postage stamps portraying slain Kashmir militant commander Burhan Wani
  1. Saudi Arabia intercepts missile shot towards border city
  2. Saudi Arabia intercepts missile shot towards border city
  1. Rahul terms Sitharaman 'Rafale Minister', demands resignation
  2. Rahul terms Sitharaman 'Rafale Minister', demands resignation
  1. US demands North Korea denuclearise by January 2021
  2. US demands North Korea denuclearise by January 2021
  1. Watch | 30 passengers suffer nose, ear bleeds after Jet Airways crew forgets to press a switch
  2. Watch | 30 passengers suffer nose, ear bleeds after Jet Airways crew forgets to press a switch
  1. Hyderabad man attacks daughter, son-in-law over inter-caste marriage
  2. Hyderabad man attacks daughter, son-in-law over inter-caste marriage
  1. Sharif family reaches Lahore after court reprieve
  2. Sharif family reaches Lahore after court reprieve
  1. Palestinian teen shot dead by Israeli fire in Gaza border clashes: ministry
  2. Palestinian teen shot dead by Israeli fire in Gaza border clashes: ministry
  1. UN urges peace in Yemen to avoid 'full-blown' famine
  2. UN urges peace in Yemen to avoid 'full-blown' famine
  1. Moon, Kim take historic trip to sacred North Korean mountain
  2. Moon, Kim take historic trip to sacred North Korean mountain
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine