Jaitley compares Indira Gandhi to Hitler

Jaitley, whose second blog of a three-part series coincided with the 43rd anniversary of imposition of the Emergency, also noted that unlike the German dictator, Gandhi went ahead to transform India into a "dynastic democracy".

Indo-Asian News Service
New Delhi, Publish Date: Jun 25 2018 4:54PM | Updated Date: Jun 25 2018 4:54PM
Jaitley compares Indira Gandhi to HitlerFile Photo

Union Minister Arun Jaitley on Monday compared former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, who imposed Emergency, to Hitler, stating that both used the Constitution "to transform democracy into dictatorship".

Jaitley, whose second blog of a three-part series coincided with the 43rd anniversary of imposition of the Emergency, also noted that unlike the German dictator, Gandhi went ahead to transform India into a "dynastic democracy". 

"Both Hitler and Gandhi never abrogated the Constitution. They used a republican Constitution to transform democracy into dictatorship," he said. 

The BJP leader said Gandhi imposed Emergency under Article 352, suspended fundamental rights under Article 359 and claimed that disorder was planned by the opposition. 

Jaitley said Hitler, who became the German Chancellor on January 30, 1933, got his President to invoke Article 48 of the country's Constitution which gave emergency powers for the "protection of people in the State". 

"The decree giving emergency powers put restrictions on personal liberty, free speech... The pretext for imposition of Emergency was that on February 27, 1933, German Parliament House, known as 'Reichstag', had been set on fire. 

"Hitler claimed that it was a communist conspiracy to burn Government buildings and museums. Thirteen years later, in the Nuremberg trials, it was established that Reichstag fire was the handiwork of Nazis and Goebbels had conceived it."

He said Hitler arrested most opposition MPs. 

"Indira Gandhi arrested most opposition MPs and, therefore, procured, through their absence, a two-third majority of members present and voting and enabling the passage of several obnoxious provisions through Constitution amendments," Jaitley said. 

The BJP leader said the 42nd Amendment diluted the power of High Courts to issue writ petitions, "a power which Dr. (B.R.) Ambedkar had said was the very heart and soul of India's Constitution".

"They also amended Article 368 so that a Constitution amendment was beyond judicial review. There were a few things that Hitler did not do which Gandhi did. 

"She prohibited the publication of Parliamentary proceeding in the media. The law which gave mandate to the media for publishing Parliamentary proceedings was popularly known as the Feroze Gandhi Bill," he said. 

Since Hitler's own election has been set aside, he had no change to make in this regard. 

"Gandhi amended both the Constitution and the Representation of People Act. The Constitution amendment made the election of the Prime Minister non-justiciable before a court. 

"The Representation of People Act was retrospectively amended to insert those provisions so that the invalid election of Gandhi could be validated by changes in law."

He said amendments to the constitution made during Emergency were later reversed by the Janata Party government. 

Latest News

  1. Girl suffers cardiac arrest after brother allegedly picked up army in south Kashmir
  2. Girl suffers cardiac arrest after brother allegedly picked up army in south Kashmir
  1. Cabinet approves increase in honorarium for Anganwadi and Asha workers
  2. Cabinet approves increase in honorarium for Anganwadi and Asha workers
  1. Watch | Doors of Holy Kaaba opened for Pakistan PM Imran Khan
  2. Watch | Doors of Holy Kaaba opened for Pakistan PM Imran Khan
  1. Cabinet nod to extension of special package for Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Cabinet nod to extension of special package for Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Provide adequate security to candidates contesting civic elections: Guv Malik
  2. Provide adequate security to candidates contesting civic elections: Guv Malik
  1. India, Pakistan Asia Cup cricket match: NIT orders closure of shops on campus
  2. India, Pakistan Asia Cup cricket match: NIT orders closure of shops on campus
  1. ICC opens probe into Myanmar's treatment of Rohingyas
  2. ICC opens probe into Myanmar's treatment of Rohingyas
  1. Pakistan court suspends jail terms of Sharifs
  2. Pakistan court suspends jail terms of Sharifs
  1. Watch | Jammu and Kashmir Congress to participate in upcoming municipal, panchayat polls: G A Mir
  2. Watch | Jammu and Kashmir Congress to participate in upcoming municipal, panchayat polls: G A Mir
  1. Two BSF men, civilian driver killed in Banihal truck accident
  2. Two BSF men, civilian driver killed in Banihal truck accident
  1. UP ATS arrests BSF soldier 'honey-trapped' by ISI
  2. UP ATS arrests BSF soldier 'honey-trapped' by ISI
  1. BSF man's throat slit on Jammu border; high alert sounded along border
  2. BSF man's throat slit on Jammu border; high alert sounded along border
  1. Watch: Police use batons, tear gas shells to foil Muharram procession in Kashmir capital
  2. Watch: Police use batons, tear gas shells to foil Muharram procession in Kashmir capital
  1. Police detain Shia mourners to foil Muharram procession in Kashmir capital
  2. Police detain Shia mourners to foil Muharram procession in Kashmir capital
  1. Cabinet approves ordinance on triple talaq
  2. Cabinet approves ordinance on triple talaq
  1. Lorries crash into fruit shops after collision in central Kashmir
  2. Lorries crash into fruit shops after collision in central Kashmir
  1. Unimpressive India beat spirited Hong Kong by 26 runs in Asia Cup
  2. Unimpressive India beat spirited Hong Kong by 26 runs in Asia Cup
  1. Pakistan PM Imran Khan in Saudi Arabia on maiden foreign visit
  2. Pakistan PM Imran Khan in Saudi Arabia on maiden foreign visit
  1. Insurance for civil poll candidates: Mirwaiz dubs it as bait to entrap people
  2. Insurance for civil poll candidates: Mirwaiz dubs it as bait to entrap people
  1. Srinagar held hostage by rulers to disallow Muharram procession: Mirwaiz
  2. Srinagar held hostage by rulers to disallow Muharram procession: Mirwaiz
  1. Kashmir police issues route advisory in view of curbs in Srinagar
  2. Kashmir police issues route advisory in view of curbs in Srinagar
  1. Restrictions in Kashmir capital to prevent Muharram processions
  2. Restrictions in Kashmir capital to prevent Muharram processions
  1. TB remains world's deadliest infectious disease: WHO
  2. TB remains world's deadliest infectious disease: WHO
  1. Five million Yemeni children face famine: NGO
  2. Five million Yemeni children face famine: NGO
  1. Israel violates Syrian sovereignty: Putin tells Netanyahu
  2. Israel violates Syrian sovereignty: Putin tells Netanyahu
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine