Aadhaar for PAN, ITR: SC questions maintainability of plea

The counsel, appearing for petitioner Binoy Viswam, a CPI leader, later withdrew the plea.

PTI
New Delhi, Publish Date: Nov 18 2017 12:28AM | Updated Date: Nov 18 2017 12:28AM
Aadhaar for PAN, ITR: SC questions maintainability of pleaFile Photo

The Supreme Court today questioned the maintainability of a petition challenging the provision mandating linking of Aadhaar with PAN number and for filing income tax returns.

The top court said it had already upheld the validity of an Income Tax Act provision making Aadhaar mandatory for the allotment of permanent account number (PAN) and filing of tax returns in its judgment delivered in June this year.

"How this petition is maintainable now? We had upheld the vires (of the provision). Now, a judgment on right to privacy has come but there is no judgement on Aadhaar. How this petition has been filed?," a bench comprising justices A K Sikri and Ashok Bhushan asked.

The counsel, appearing for petitioner Binoy Viswam, a CPI leader, later withdrew the plea.

The bench granted him the liberty to file an application for intervention in the main Aadhaar matter which is scheduled to come up for hearing before a Constitution bench in the last week of this month.

The top court had on June 9 upheld section 139AA of the Income Tax Act making Aadhaar mandatory for allotment of PAN cards and filing of tax returns, but had put a partial stay on its implementation till a Constitution bench addressed the issue of right to privacy. Later, the Constitution bench had declared right to privacy as a fundamental right.

Section 139AA of the Income Tax Act provides for mandatory quoting of Aadhaar or enrolment ID of Aadhaar application form for filing of income tax returns and making application for allotment of PAN with effect from July 1 this year. Meanwhile, the apex court today also refused to hear a separate petition which had challenged the linking of Aadhaar with bank accounts.

The court said it cannot hear several petitions raising similar issue and asked the petitioner to move an application for intervention in the main Aadhaar matter. 

 

Latest News

  1. Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister condemns killing of bank guards
  2. Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister condemns killing of bank guards
  1. Srinagar-Jammu highway closed for traffic after rains, snow
  2. Srinagar-Jammu highway closed for traffic after rains, snow
  1. Mentally unsound youth missing in Srinagar; police seeks help
  2. Mentally unsound youth missing in Srinagar; police seeks help
  1. Mirwaiz condemns killing of woman in Handwara, security guards in Shopian
  2. Mirwaiz condemns killing of woman in Handwara, security guards in Shopian
  1. Winter break announced for colleges in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Winter break announced for colleges in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Rahul Gandhi elected Congress President
  2. Rahul Gandhi elected Congress President
  1. Militants killed in Handwara gunfight belonged to LeT: Police
  2. Militants killed in Handwara gunfight belonged to LeT: Police
  1. Man arrested for faking theft of two-wheeler in Srinagar: Police
  2. Man arrested for faking theft of two-wheeler in Srinagar: Police
  1. Video: Two security guards killed in cash van attack in south Kashmir’s Shopian
  2. Video: Two security guards killed in cash van attack in south Kashmir’s Shopian
  1. Manmohan tells Modi to apologize for 'falsehood and canards'
  2. Manmohan tells Modi to apologize for 'falsehood and canards'
  1. Rasheed leads protest march in Handwara, blames army for killing of woman in gunfight
  2. Rasheed leads protest march in Handwara, blames army for killing of woman in gunfight
  1. Talk about Gujarat, not Pakistan: Rahul to Modi
  2. Talk about Gujarat, not Pakistan: Rahul to Modi
  1. Pro-freedom slogans raised during funeral of woman killed in Handwara gunfight
  2. Pro-freedom slogans raised during funeral of woman killed in Handwara gunfight
  1. Policeman injured in last week's accidental fire in south Kashmir succumbs
  2. Policeman injured in last week's accidental fire in south Kashmir succumbs
  1. North Kashmir: Rickshaw driver beaten for trying to 'overtake' army vehicle in Ajas
  2. North Kashmir: Rickshaw driver beaten for trying to 'overtake' army vehicle in Ajas
  1. Army porter slips to death in Gurez in north Kashmir
  2. Army porter slips to death in Gurez in north Kashmir
  1. Cannot direct Jammu and Kashmir Legislature to constitute State Minority Commission: SC
  2. Cannot direct Jammu and Kashmir Legislature to constitute State Minority Commission: SC
  1. Congress demands apology from Modi over 'insinuations' on Pakistan links
  2. Congress demands apology from Modi over 'insinuations' on Pakistan links
  1. Death toll in highway accident climbs to six in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Death toll in highway accident climbs to six in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. California wildfire bigger than New York city
  2. California wildfire bigger than New York city
  1. After Modi's remark of secret meeting, Pakistan tells India don't drag us into your politics
  2. After Modi's remark of secret meeting, Pakistan tells India don't drag us into your politics
  1. US, Pakistan engage in quiet diplomacy to improve ties
  2. US, Pakistan engage in quiet diplomacy to improve ties
  1. Top firms not hiring women as cyber security officers: Report
  2. Top firms not hiring women as cyber security officers: Report
  1. Shatrughan Sinha questions Modi over 'unbelievable' tales against opponents
  2. Shatrughan Sinha questions Modi over 'unbelievable' tales against opponents
  1. Mehbooba Mufti praises administrative skills of Sheikh Abdullah
  2. Mehbooba Mufti praises administrative skills of Sheikh Abdullah
  1. Bad weather disrupts traffic on Mughal Road in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Bad weather disrupts traffic on Mughal Road in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Overnight rains break dry cold spell in Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Overnight rains break dry cold spell in Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Bandipora-Gurez road closed after heavy snowfall
  2. Bandipora-Gurez road closed after heavy snowfall
  1. Earthquake of 4.5 magnitude hits Jammu and Kashmir
  2. Earthquake of 4.5 magnitude hits Jammu and Kashmir
  1. Protests in Handwara against woman’s killing during gunfight
  2. Protests in Handwara against woman’s killing during gunfight
  1. Video | Kashmir: Three militants, civilian killed in Handwara gunfight, says police
  2. Video | Kashmir: Three militants, civilian killed in Handwara gunfight, says police